• 목록
• 답변
• 글쓰기
• 게시판 리스트 옵션
  • 수정
  • 삭제

OnlyFans has put X-rated leisure within the arms of its entertainers. Call it the paywall of porn.

Dannii Harwood Credit...Molly Matalon for The new York Times



By Jacob Bernstein

Feb. 9, 2019
Day by day, a whole bunch of males pay Dannii Harwood to enact their sexual fantasies and increase their shallowness. Sometimes her clothes come off. Sometimes she dresses up as a nurse or a dominatrix.

If a man is a regular buyer, she seemingly is aware of his birthday, the names of his youngsters and his pets - even when to name after a surgical procedure.

He might pay her to help him obtain an orgasm, although she just isn't a prostitute. He might buy erotic movies from her, although she isn't a porn star.

Ms. Harwood is one of the highest earners on OnlyFans, the place subscribers - principally male; straight, gay and beyond - pay fashions and social media influencers a fee, generally $5 to $20 a month, to view a feed of imagery too racy for Instagram. With that access, subscribers can even direct message and "tip" to get photos or videos created on demand, in line with their sexual tastes.

Models who be a part of the site typically presume that their subscribers will enhance in quantity in the event that they publish extra usually and make the content material extra express. The "more often" part is true. The "more explicit" half will not be.

At a time when anybody with a smartphone or small studio can change into his or her own pornographer, and content is usually free, the hottest site in the grownup leisure trade is dominated by suppliers who present fewer intercourse acts and cost increasing charges relying on how creative the requests get.

That’s the primary paradox at the center of the OnlyFans phenomenon.

Jem Wolfie and Matthew Camp, Businesspeople

The preferred OnlyFans character is Jem Wolfie, of Perth, Australia.

She can’t assist but laugh when folks name her a "fitness mannequin." As she famous in an interview, "70 % of my fans are males." So the majority of them aren’t in search of train suggestions, although she may provide them, for an added fee (along with wholesome recipes - she used to be a chef).

In keeping with OnlyFans, she has 10,000 subscribers who pay $10 a month for entry to a feed during which she exhibits off her Kardashianesque proportions, squatting in really tight leggings and squeezing her breasts collectively, strategically overlaying her nipples. "I’m a thick lady," she mentioned matter-of-factly.

It doesn’t go much further than that.

"Basically, OnlyFans is online go-go dancing," stated Matthew Camp, a 34-yr-old model on the men’s side who broke into the business a decade ago writhing on platforms around downtown Manhattan for the social gathering promoter Susanne Bartsch.

If the four main quadrants of the gay approval matrix were daddy, twink, bear and boy next door, he seemed to sit smack in the middle, not falling neatly into any of those classes but interesting to the potential audiences for each.

With a G-string and a strobe gentle, he might make as much as $1,000 on an excellent night. Porn studios like Lucas Entertainment began calling.

Mr. Camp was intrigued. "Having intercourse for cash is interesting," he stated. But $1,000 appeared low for one thing that will sit on the internet and model him for all times as a porn star.

So he turned them down and as a substitute used a PG-13 feed on Instagram to construct a following of more than half a million. A couple of 12 months in the past, as the club scene continued its gradual demise, he moved to Hudson, N.Y., and signed up for OnlyFans.

Weeks usually went by with out him posting a single image or video. He didn’t present a full penetrative sex clip for the primary nine months, yet he nonetheless recurrently took house more than $10,000 a month.

"Tumblr was filled with probably the most extreme sexual experiences you could see," he mentioned. "And I think lots of people were turned off by that. It’s not what they’re on the lookout for. They want more intimate experiences. They need a boyfriend experience. They want to fantasize about someone that they want to have intercourse with and never feel disgusted by it."

How the Internet Destabilized Pornography

From the late nineties to the early 2000s, dreamers in the porn industry, centered in the San Fernando Valley of California, openly described their multi-million-dollar futures within the business. There was actually a historical past of this occurring, at the very least for a small variety of fashions signed to profitable lengthy-term contracts with studios like Vivid and Wicked.

They could make north of $5,000 a scene and shoot a few those each week, in accordance with Brian Gross, a well-known industry publicist. That income could be supplemented with five-figure sums doing nightclub appearances around the country on the weekends, he stated.

Jenna Jameson - the Julia Roberts of straight porn - even parlayed her notoriety right into a memoir released by HarperCollins, "How to Make Love Like a Porn Star: A Cautionary Tale," which was a new York Times best vendor. The title turned out to be eerily prescient. As its publisher, Judith Regan, identified: "Porn went the way in which of all media." It turns out, everybody might do it.

Except that because porn was an trade of people already residing on the margins of society, the consequences for the performers have been in many ways worse.

The first culprits had been so-referred to as tube sites: YouTube-like platforms that aggregated stolen pornographic content, disseminated it for free and sucked up income from banner and video adverts.

Since porn studios didn't have the capital or political connections to sue their most threatening adversaries out of business (because the file industry did), charges for scene work dropped. Fewer scenes have been shot overall. Eventually, the studios started promoting themselves to the tube websites at hearth-sale costs.

It was as if the whole music enterprise had been subsumed by Napster.

By 2015, a handful of firms had been able to exert monopolistic control over the trade. MindGeek is the most important player of all. The crown jewel of its empire is Pornhub (perhaps the most popular tube site on the earth), which is provided with content from quite a few in-home production firms of the straight (Brazzers.com, Reality Kings) and gay varieties (SeanCody, Men.com).

MindGeek is aware of all about porn habits by doing complete data evaluation. It has proven less of an affinity for the product or the individuals who appear in it.

The MindGeek website makes no reference to the fact that the overwhelming majority of its customers are customers of exhausting-core pornography.

The technocrats who built the corporate obtained wealthy. Lots of the performers who helped enable their success became prostitutes, providing their providers on websites like RentMen.com and The Erotic Review when scene work ceased to be a viable approach to make a residing.

It’s a fitting but unlucky parable in an period of rampant economic inequality.

"If you could have a recognized name, it’s much easier to market your providers," mentioned Dirk Caber, a porn star who has filmed close to forty scenes for MindGeek’s most popular gay site, Men.com, since 2013. Most of his earnings comes from his work as an escort, as a result of this scene work pays so little.

"The complete business did a 180," Mr. Gross mentioned. "When I began, there have been truly websites that might out famous porn stars in the event that they escorted, as a result of it was shocking, for lack of a greater phrase. Now, all expertise is looked at as if they are escorts, and those that aren’t have to come back out and say so."

Your ‘Online Girlfriend’

One alternative to escorting is webcamming. In England, there are even Tv stations, like Playboy and Babestation, on which models talk live with thousands of customers and earn a number of hundred dollars a day.

That’s what Ms. Harwood did before OnlyFans came along.

She grew up in Wales, with a mom who stocked supermarket shelves and a father who was a factory worker.

It was a "typical working-class" family, she stated not too long ago, whereas on a vacation in New York that included a visit to the 9/11 memorial and the taking of many hotel room selfies.

As a little bit woman, Ms. Harwood was a relentless consideration seeker, the kind who appeared in class performs, competed in beauty pageants and studied dance. She additionally had reservoirs of empathy that will serve her well later in life.

She could spot ache in others and find ways to make them feel higher. She also was able to figuring out her limitations and finding ways to chart new paths for herself. "I was raised nicely," she mentioned.

She studied dance at Laine Theatre Arts, a prestigious drama and dance school near London. Then, "I went to audition after audition," she stated. "Eventually, I realized I wasn’t adequate. And it was fairly hard to accept at first."

Around 2005, Ms. Harwood posed topless on Page 3 of The Daily Sport, a second-tier British newspaper that she said "was fashionable with day laborers and building employees."

This apparently included the guys her father worked with.

One morning, he went into work and saw the image of his daughter plastered to his locker.

On her face, his colleagues had drawn his mustache and glasses. That’s how he discovered she was modeling nude. That’s why he warned her about being disowned.

Ms. Harwood felt terrible. Although she likes taking off her clothes for different folks, she seems driven much less by the desire to transgress than the desire to please. If she had been reincarnated as a Disney character, she’d be Jessica Rabbit, not Miss Piggy.

But it surely wasn’t like her father had the money to help her. His warning was kind of an empty risk. So she stored going, with appearances in Playboy and British so-called laddie magazines.

In 2011, Ms. Harwood labored for a delicate-core site referred to as GlamGirls and grew to become pleasant with its owner, Tim Stokely, an earnest technocrat who seems to be like Mark Zuckerberg by way of Savile Row. Soon after, Mr. Stokely based a site referred to as Customs4U, which Ms. Harwood stated, lightheartedly, might have been her concept and was like OnlyFans in beta.

The pitch was to offer horny guys the power to grow to be their own administrators, ordering specifically made videos from their favorite models.

It sputtered alongside whereas Instagram - which is free and doesn’t enable full nudity - took off. Then Mr. Stokely had his light bulb moment: Why not find a method for influencers to immediately monetize their content material. The platform - OnlyFans - would be much like Instagram or Twitter besides fans must pay a monthly subscription to view influencers’ content and work together with them.

It will therefore be a pure bolt-on to the influencer’s present social media. A free feed on Instagram or Twitter might promote and drive site visitors to the subscription-solely feed on OnlyFans.

Eighty p.c of the charges collected for each feed would go to the supplier. Twenty p.c would go to OnlyFans (though after merchant and processing fees, Mr. Stokely says its take is round 12 %). This is roughly the same arrangement Uber has with its drivers, except that OnlyFans didn’t push performers towards poverty by dictating the prices they may cost.

When OnlyFans started, in 2016, Ms. Harwood was one in every of simply 10 models who sought subscribers. She didn’t think a lot would come of it initially. Her earnings for the first month have been $257.

Then, the positioning added options enabling models to create custom content material. Ms. Harwood obtained inventive.

She introduced themed days like Mistress Mondays and Dare Dannii Tuesdays, when men bid to look at her drive round town in her underwear and order a pizza to her dwelling, whereupon she would answer the door bare. She additionally chatted with followers every day, learning their habits, their sexual predilections and their insecurities.

"You can get porn totally free," she said. "Guys don’t wish to pay for that. They need the opportunity to get to know somebody they’ve seen in a journal or on social media. I’m like their on-line girlfriend."

Ms. Harwood took out her phone and confirmed proof of her principle.

She introduced dwelling $29,420.47 in August, $34,303.24 in September, $52,693.29 in October and $52,760.49 in November.

The Wizards of Porn

Although OnlyFans has brilliantly capitalized off the life’s work of exhibitionists, it's run by folks whose most apparent trait is opacity.

That’s the second paradox at the center of its existence.

There isn't any webpage for Fenix International Limited, which is the mum or dad firm of OnlyFans. It does have a publicist, Daniel Blythe, who largely helps the males behind it avoid interviews.

When i first contacted Mr. Blythe, in November, informing him of my intention to jot down about OnlyFans, he was affable as might be for a man with no intention of disclosing the names of his clients, much much less submitting them to an interview.

After i did discover Mr. Stokely’s title and parts of his again story, with a little bit assist from somebody on Reddit, Mr. Blythe provided the warmest of congratulations. "Refreshing to know that investigative journalism isn’t useless," he said.

Still, the perfect he could provide were written responses to questions for Mr. Stokely, the company’s chief govt. The solutions had been maddeningly vague, however Mr. Stokely did say that he works at Fenix along with his father, Guy Stokely, who, earlier than changing into its chairman, was an investment banker with Barclays, onlyfootfetish.org the storied British financial institution.

Mr. Stokely also confirmed that certainly one of Fenix’s directors is Leo Radvinsky, a 2003 Northwestern University graduate who went on to start out MyFreeCams (one of the industry’s largest chat websites) and who has been a defendant in three lawsuits related to phishing makes an attempt and patent infringement. (Mr. Blythe stated he couldn't comment on the status of these lawsuits because they "do not pertain to OnlyFans.")

There’s No App for That

Mr. Stokely is desirous to take OnlyFans out of the pornography niche and make it a platform for all kinds of influencers and audiences.

One hurdle is that there is no iPhone app. The platform because it exists now possible runs afoul of Apple’s restrictions on "overtly sexual or pornographic materials." And even when Apple did enable an OnlyFans app, the fees - 30 percent - would actually be an issue, Mr. Stokely stated. He must go along these expenses to performers.

Technical issues on OnlyFans additionally threaten its longevity and assist clarify why synonymous websites, equivalent to JustFor.Fans, have managed to siphon off appreciable numbers of performers and income.

Still, Chanel Santini, a 21-12 months-outdated performer who has been with OnlyFans for more than a 12 months and earns at least $8,000 a month in subscription revenue, can’t muster severe complaints.

Not when she experienced the choice.

She grew up in Albuquerque with a single mother who was a hairdresser. Ms. Santini came out as transgender when she was a teenager. That acquired her thrown out of the home. She never finished highschool.

In 2015, Ms. Santini moved to Las Vegas and took a job as a clerk at Hollister, the clothes chain. Even in a metropolis with a reasonably low value of residing, it wasn’t sufficient.

So she began doing porn, filming scenes that paid as little as $400, which then led to escorting. She labored for a madam who stole her money, she stated, and threatened her with violence.

With standard feeds on Instagram and Twitter, Ms. Santini’s identify acquired greater. OnlyFans started and she signed up.

A couple of weeks ago, she burst into tears over the cellphone whereas recalling her first pornographic shoot. There, a director had instructed her that the one solution to make a residing in porn was to also be a prostitute.

"He stated that straight to my face," she said. "Now, I simply want to run into him once more, so I can say, ‘Well, here I am. I’m pulling in tens of thousands of dollars each month simply posting content online. I don’t need to escort anymore. I don’t have to try this. Guess you have been fallacious!’"

An earlier model of this text misstated the type of surf break at Playa Negra. It's a proper-hand break, not a left-hand break.

How we handle corrections